What Is Buy to Cover and How Does It Work?

ByObeydul Haque Reading Time: 6 minutes

Buy to cover refers to the purchase of an equivalent number of shares to those borrowed and sold in a short sale, with the intent to return them to the lender (typically the broker). This action “covers” the short position, closing the trade and eliminating the trader’s liability for the borrowed shares. Essentially, it’s the process of exiting a short sale.

When you initiate a short sale, you create an open position with an obligation to return the borrowed shares at some point. The buy-to-cover order is executed when you’re ready to close that position—whether because the stock price has dropped (locking in a profit), risen (cutting a loss), or for other strategic reasons.

How Does Buy to Cover Work?

To understand how buy to cover operates, let’s break it down into a step-by-step process within the context of short selling:

  1. Opening a Short Position:
    • You identify a stock you believe will decline in value.
    • Through a margin account (required for short selling), you borrow shares from your broker.
    • You sell these borrowed shares in the open market, receiving cash from the sale.
  2. Monitoring the Market:
    • After selling the shares, you wait for the stock price to move. If it falls, you’re in a profitable position; if it rises, you’re facing a potential loss.
    • During this time, you may incur costs like borrowing fees (for holding the short position) and margin interest (since short selling involves borrowing).
  3. Executing a Buy-to-Cover Order:
    • When you decide to close the short position, you place a buy-to-cover order through your brokerage platform.
    • This order instructs the broker to purchase the same number of shares you initially borrowed and sold.
    • The purchased shares are returned to the lender, fulfilling your obligation.
  4. Settling the Trade:
    • The difference between the price at which you sold the shares and the price at which you bought them back determines your profit or loss.
    • Additional costs, such as commissions, borrowing fees, and dividends (if the company paid any during the short period), are deducted from your account.

Types of Buy-to-Cover Orders

Buy-to-cover orders can be executed in various ways, depending on the trader’s strategy and market conditions. Common order types include:

  • Market Order: A buy-to-cover market order instructs the broker to purchase the shares immediately at the best available price. This is useful for quickly closing a position but carries the risk of price slippage in volatile markets.
  • Limit Order: A buy-to-cover limit order specifies a maximum price you’re willing to pay to repurchase the shares. The order only executes if the stock price falls to or below your limit, offering price control but no guarantee of execution.
  • Stop Order: A buy-to-cover stop order triggers a purchase when the stock reaches a specified price (the stop price). This is often used to limit losses if the stock price rises unexpectedly.

Why Do Traders Use Buy to Cover?

Traders use buy-to-cover orders for several reasons, each tied to their goals and market outlook:

  1. Locking in Profits:
    • If the stock price drops as anticipated, a trader may issue a buy-to-cover order to repurchase the shares at a lower price, securing the profit from the price difference.
  2. Cutting Losses:
    • If the stock price rises, a trader may buy to cover to limit further losses. Short selling carries theoretically unlimited risk since a stock’s price can rise indefinitely.
  3. Responding to Market Events:
    • News, earnings reports, or other events may prompt a trader to close their position, either to capitalize on a temporary price drop or avoid unexpected volatility.
  4. Margin Calls:
    • If the stock price rises significantly, the broker may issue a margin call, requiring the trader to deposit additional funds or close the position. A buy-to-cover order is used to comply.
  5. Strategic Exits:
    • A trader may decide to exit a short position for reasons unrelated to price movement, such as reallocating capital or reducing portfolio risk.

Risks and Challenges of Buy to Cover

While buy to cover is a straightforward concept, executing it effectively involves navigating several risks and challenges inherent to short selling:

  1. Unlimited Loss Potential:
    • Unlike buying a stock (where the maximum loss is the amount invested), short selling has no upper limit on losses. If a stock’s price skyrockets, the cost to buy to cover can be exorbitant.
  2. Short Squeeze:
    • A short squeeze occurs when a heavily shorted stock’s price rises rapidly, forcing short sellers to buy to cover to limit losses. This buying frenzy pushes the price even higher, exacerbating losses for remaining short sellers.
  3. Borrowing Costs:
    • Short selling involves borrowing fees, which can accumulate over time, especially for stocks in high demand for shorting (known as “hard-to-borrow” stocks).
  4. Dividend Payments:
    • If the company pays a dividend while you hold a short position, you’re responsible for paying it to the lender, increasing your costs.
  5. Margin Requirements:
    • Short selling requires a margin account, and brokers impose maintenance margin requirements. If the stock price rises, you may need to deposit more capital or face a forced buy-to-cover order.
  6. Timing Risks:
    • Predicting when a stock price will fall is challenging. Even if your analysis is correct, the timing may be off, leading to losses or missed opportunities.

Strategies for Effective Buy to Cover

To mitigate risks and enhance the success of short selling and buy-to-cover trades, traders employ various strategies:

  1. Technical Analysis:
    • Use charts, indicators, and patterns (e.g., moving averages, RSI) to identify overbought stocks or potential price reversals, guiding when to short and when to buy to cover.
  2. Fundamental Analysis:
    • Evaluate a company’s financial health, industry trends, and news to identify overvalued stocks likely to decline, informing your short-selling decisions.
  3. Stop-Loss Orders:
    • Place buy-to-cover stop orders to automatically close a position if the stock price rises beyond a certain level, capping potential losses.
  4. Position Sizing:
    • Limit the size of your short position to manage risk. Avoid over-leveraging, as it can amplify losses and trigger margin calls.
  5. Monitoring Borrowing Costs:
    • Be aware of the fees for borrowing shares, especially for stocks with high short interest, and factor them into your profit calculations.
  6. Hedging:
    • Use options, such as buying call options on the same stock, to hedge against a potential price surge, reducing the risk of large losses.

Real-World Example of Buy to Cover

Let’s walk through a hypothetical scenario to illustrate how buy to cover works in practice:

  • Step 1: You research Company ABC, which is trading at $50 per share. Based on poor earnings reports, you believe the stock is overvalued and will drop to $40.
  • Step 2: You borrow 200 shares through your broker and sell them at $50, receiving $10,000.
  • Step 3: Over the next two weeks, the stock falls to $42. You decide to lock in your profit and place a buy-to-cover market order.
  • Step 4: You repurchase 200 shares at $42, costing $8,400. The shares are returned to the broker.
  • Step 5: Your gross profit is $10,000 – $8,400 = $1,600. After subtracting $100 in borrowing fees and $20 in commissions, your net profit is $1,480.

Now, consider an alternative scenario:

  • The stock rises to $60 instead of falling. To limit losses, you place a buy-to-cover order at $60, spending $12,000 to repurchase the 200 shares.
  • Your loss is $10,000 – $12,000 = -$2,000, plus fees, resulting in a net loss of approximately $2,120.

These examples highlight both the potential rewards and risks of short selling and the critical role of the buy-to-cover order.

Buy to Cover vs. Other Trading Actions

It’s worth distinguishing buy to cover from other trading actions to avoid confusion:

  • Buy to Cover vs. Buy: A standard “buy” order purchases shares to hold as an investment (going long), while buy to cover closes a short position by repurchasing borrowed shares.
  • Buy to Cover vs. Cover: In options trading, “covering” refers to selling a call option against owned shares (a covered call). Buy to cover is specific to short selling stocks.
  • Buy to Cover vs. Close Position: While both terms can mean exiting a trade, “close position” is broader and applies to any trade, whereas buy to cover specifically closes a short sale.

Regulatory Considerations

Short selling and buy-to-cover orders are subject to regulations to maintain market stability:

  • SEC Rules: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) enforces rules like Regulation SHO, which governs short selling practices, including locating shares to borrow before shorting.
  • Uptick Rule: In some markets, short selling is restricted to upticks (when the stock price rises) to prevent excessive downward pressure on prices.
  • Margin Requirements: Brokers must adhere to Federal Reserve and FINRA margin rules, ensuring traders maintain sufficient account equity for short positions.

Traders should familiarize themselves with these regulations to avoid penalties or forced liquidations.

Conclusion

Buy to cover is a fundamental component of short selling, enabling traders to close their positions and realize profits or limit losses. By borrowing shares, selling them, and later repurchasing them through a buy-to-cover order, traders can capitalize on declining stock prices. However, the strategy comes with significant risks, including unlimited loss potential, short squeezes, and borrowing costs. Successful short selling requires careful analysis, disciplined risk management, and strategic timing.

I (plan to) write about business, finance, SEO, WordPress, and whatever else interests me. You might find those interesting too. For now, find me on Twitter/ X.